简答题
经济法
题号 #5494749
A公司为支付货款,向B公司签发了一张金额为200万元的银行承兑汇票,某商业银行作为承兑人在票面上签章。B公司收到汇票后将其背书转让给c公司,以偿还所欠C公司的租金,但未在被背书人栏内记载C公司的名称。C公司欠D公司一笔应付账款,遂直接将D公司记载为B公司的被背书人,并将汇票交给D公司。D公司随后又将汇票背书转让给E公司,用于偿付工程款,并于票据上注明:“工程验收合格则转让生效。”
D公司与E公司因工程存在严重质量问题,未能验收合格而发生纠纷。纠纷期间,E公司为支付广告费,欲将汇票背书转让给F公司。F公司负责人知悉D公司与E公司之间存在工程纠纷,对该汇票产生疑虑,遂要求E公司之关联企业G公司与F公司签订了一份保证合同。该保证合同约定,G公司就E公司对F公司承担的票据责任提供连带责任保证。但是,G公司未在汇票上记载任何内容,亦未签章。
F公司于汇票到期日向银行提示付款,银行以A公司未在该行存人足额资金为由拒绝付款。F公司遂向C、D、E、G公司追索。
要求:根据上述内容.分别回答下列问题。
(1)C公司是否应向F公司承担票据责任?并说明理由。
(2)D公司对E公司的背书转让是否生效?并说明理由。
(3)D公司能否以其与E公司的工程纠纷尚未解决为由,拒绝向F公司承担票据责任?并说明理由。
(4)F公司能否向G公司行使票据上的追索权?并说明理由。
(5)G公司是否应向F公司承担保证责任?并说明理由。
参考答案
暂无
答案解析
(1)C公司不应向F公司承担票据责任。由于C公司未在汇票上签章,因此不是票据法律关系的当事人,不应承担任何票据责任。
(2)D公司对E公司的背书转让生效。根据票据法律制度的规定,背书时附有条件的,所附条件不具有汇票上的效力。
(3)D公司可以以其与E公司的工程纠纷尚未解决为由,拒绝向F公司承担票据责任。根据票据法律制度的规定,票据债务人不得以自己与持票人的前手之间的抗辩事由,对抗持票人。但是持票人明知存在抗辩事由而取得票据的除外。F公司明知D公司与E公司发生的工程纠纷尚未解决,却仍然接受汇票,故其权利不能优先于其前手E公司。
(4)F公司不能向G公司行使票据上的追索权。根据票据法律制度的规定,办理票据保证手续时,应在票据上记载保证文句并由保证人签章。G公司未在票据上记载任何内容。亦未签章,其行为不构成票据保证,G公司不属于票据债务人,故F公司不能向其行使票据上的追索权。
(5)G公司应向F公司承担保证责任。尽管G公司不存在票据上的保证责任.但G公司与F公司签订了保证合同,适用《担保法》有关保证责任的规定。作为连带责任保证人.在E公司不履行债务时,G公司应当承担保证责任。
Correct answers :
( 1 ) C is not 1iable to F for the bill of exchange. Since C did not sign or seal on the bill, it is not a party to the bill re1ationship and has no bill 1iability.
(2) The endorsement that D made for E has taken effect. According to the laws on negotiable instruments,the condition imposed on the endorsement is of no effect on the bill.
(3) D may use its unsettled project dispute with E to deny its bill 1iability. According to the laws on negotia-ble instruments, a bill debtor cannot use a contradicting issue between the debtor and its prior parties to deny a claim from the bill holder, unless the bill ho1der has been aware of the contradicting issue when accepting the bill. F knew the existence of the unsettled dispute between D and E, nevertheless he accepted the bill. Hence the bill right he is entitled to could not go beyond the enjoyed by E which suffers the negative re-sult of the dispute.
(4)F cannot go after G/exert the recourse right toward G on the basis of the bill. According to the laws on negotiable instruments, a guarantee on the bill requires explicit guarantee expressions as well as signature and seal from the guarantor. G neither put down such words on the bill nor signed on it, so it is not a party to the bill.
(5) G should assume the guarantee liability toward F. There is a valid guarantee contract between F and G. As a joint and several liability guarantor for E's debt, G should be liable to F when E failed to perform his debt.
(2)D公司对E公司的背书转让生效。根据票据法律制度的规定,背书时附有条件的,所附条件不具有汇票上的效力。
(3)D公司可以以其与E公司的工程纠纷尚未解决为由,拒绝向F公司承担票据责任。根据票据法律制度的规定,票据债务人不得以自己与持票人的前手之间的抗辩事由,对抗持票人。但是持票人明知存在抗辩事由而取得票据的除外。F公司明知D公司与E公司发生的工程纠纷尚未解决,却仍然接受汇票,故其权利不能优先于其前手E公司。
(4)F公司不能向G公司行使票据上的追索权。根据票据法律制度的规定,办理票据保证手续时,应在票据上记载保证文句并由保证人签章。G公司未在票据上记载任何内容。亦未签章,其行为不构成票据保证,G公司不属于票据债务人,故F公司不能向其行使票据上的追索权。
(5)G公司应向F公司承担保证责任。尽管G公司不存在票据上的保证责任.但G公司与F公司签订了保证合同,适用《担保法》有关保证责任的规定。作为连带责任保证人.在E公司不履行债务时,G公司应当承担保证责任。
Correct answers :
( 1 ) C is not 1iable to F for the bill of exchange. Since C did not sign or seal on the bill, it is not a party to the bill re1ationship and has no bill 1iability.
(2) The endorsement that D made for E has taken effect. According to the laws on negotiable instruments,the condition imposed on the endorsement is of no effect on the bill.
(3) D may use its unsettled project dispute with E to deny its bill 1iability. According to the laws on negotia-ble instruments, a bill debtor cannot use a contradicting issue between the debtor and its prior parties to deny a claim from the bill holder, unless the bill ho1der has been aware of the contradicting issue when accepting the bill. F knew the existence of the unsettled dispute between D and E, nevertheless he accepted the bill. Hence the bill right he is entitled to could not go beyond the enjoyed by E which suffers the negative re-sult of the dispute.
(4)F cannot go after G/exert the recourse right toward G on the basis of the bill. According to the laws on negotiable instruments, a guarantee on the bill requires explicit guarantee expressions as well as signature and seal from the guarantor. G neither put down such words on the bill nor signed on it, so it is not a party to the bill.
(5) G should assume the guarantee liability toward F. There is a valid guarantee contract between F and G. As a joint and several liability guarantor for E's debt, G should be liable to F when E failed to perform his debt.