简答题
经济法
题号 #5494833
2019年2月1日,甲公司与乙公司签订买卖合同,根据合同约定,甲公司向乙公司购买一批建筑材料,价款为600万元,甲公司于2019年3月19日开出面值600万元,5个月到期的商业汇票,A保证人为甲公司保证,并在票据正面注明保证字样和保证人签章。
乙公司收到票据后按期向承兑人提示承兑,并于2019年6月9日将该票据背书转让给丙公司,丙公司又背书转让给丁公司。丁公司于2019年8月22日向承兑人提示付款。由此牵涉出以下问题:
(1)甲公司认为票据未记载付款地和出票地,记载事项不完整,拒绝付款;承兑人认为持票人未按规定期限提示付款,拒绝付款。
(2)丁公司要求乙公司付款,乙公司认为按照债务人的顺序,应先由丙公司付款,丁公司不能对其直接要求付款,因此拒绝付款。
(3)丁公司要求A担保人代为付款,A同意付款。
要求:根据上述资料,结合《票据法》的有关规定,分析回答下列问题。
(1)影响汇票有效性的记载事项有哪些?甲公司的理由能否成立?
(2)承兑人拒绝付款的理由是否成立?
(3)丁公司要求丙公司、乙公司、A代为付款,属于行使什么权利?
(4)乙公司拒绝付款的理由是否成立?并说明理由。
(5)A保证人向丁公司承担保证责任后,是否有追索权?
参考答案
暂无
答案解析
(1)影响票据效力的记载事项是绝对记载事项。汇票的绝对记载事项包括:表明“汇票”的字样;无条件支付的委托;确定的金额;付款人名称;收款人名称;出票日期;出票人签章。上述绝对记载事项缺一则该汇票无效。
出票地和付款地属于相对记载事项,记载与否不影响票据的效力,因此,甲公司拒绝付款的理由不成立。
(2)承兑人拒绝付款理由不成立。因为该票据属于出票后定期付款的汇票,持票人应在该票据到期日起10日内提示付款,丁公司提示付款的时间符合规定,因此承兑人拒绝付款理由不成立。
(3)丁公司要求丙公司、乙公司、A代为付款,属于行使票据追索权。
(4)乙公司的理由不成立,根据《票据法》的规定,持票人可以不按照汇票债务人的先后顺序,对其中任何一人、数人或者全体行使追索权。因此,乙公司所说的按照债务人的顺序,应先由丙公司付款的理由是不成立的。
(5)A保证人向丁公司承担保证责任后,享有追索权。根据《票据法》的规定,保证人向持票人清偿债务后,取得票据而成为持票人,享有票据的权利,有权对被保证人及其前手行使追索权。因此,A保证人履行了票据保证责任后,可以向出票人甲公司行使追索权。
Correct answers :
( 1 ) The records that affect the validity of the draft are absolute records. The absolute records of a draft in-cludes: Carhinese characters denoting " draft" ;commission on unconditional payment;the amount of money fixed; name of the payer; name of the payee; the date of issue; and signature of the drawer. The
draft is inva1id if lacking anyone of above items.
The p1ace of issue and the place of payment are the relative record items. Recording or not does not affect the validity of the draft. Therefore, the reason of Jia's refuse payment is false.
(2)The reason for the acceptor's refuse payment is invalid. This is a draft with payable in a defined time after the issuance, the bearer shall present the draft for payment within 10 days from the date of maturity,and the time for Ding's presentation of payment meets the requirements, so the reason for the acceptor's pay-ment rejection is inva1id.
(3) Ding who requires Bing, Yi, and A to pay on behalf of Ding is exercising the right of recourse.
(4) Yi' s reason is invalid. According to the law of Instrument, the bearer may exercise the right of recourse against any one, several or all of them without following the order of the debtor of the draft. Therefore, that Yi asking Bing to pay first, in the debtor's order, is invalid.
(5) The guarantor A has the right of recourse after he assumed the liability of guarantee. According to the law of Instrument, the guarantor becomes the bearer after he paying off the debts to the ex-bearer, and has the right of recourse against the guarantee and his predecessors. Therefore, the guarantor A can exercise the right of recourse to the drawer Jia after he fulfils his liability of guaranty.
出票地和付款地属于相对记载事项,记载与否不影响票据的效力,因此,甲公司拒绝付款的理由不成立。
(2)承兑人拒绝付款理由不成立。因为该票据属于出票后定期付款的汇票,持票人应在该票据到期日起10日内提示付款,丁公司提示付款的时间符合规定,因此承兑人拒绝付款理由不成立。
(3)丁公司要求丙公司、乙公司、A代为付款,属于行使票据追索权。
(4)乙公司的理由不成立,根据《票据法》的规定,持票人可以不按照汇票债务人的先后顺序,对其中任何一人、数人或者全体行使追索权。因此,乙公司所说的按照债务人的顺序,应先由丙公司付款的理由是不成立的。
(5)A保证人向丁公司承担保证责任后,享有追索权。根据《票据法》的规定,保证人向持票人清偿债务后,取得票据而成为持票人,享有票据的权利,有权对被保证人及其前手行使追索权。因此,A保证人履行了票据保证责任后,可以向出票人甲公司行使追索权。
Correct answers :
( 1 ) The records that affect the validity of the draft are absolute records. The absolute records of a draft in-cludes: Carhinese characters denoting " draft" ;commission on unconditional payment;the amount of money fixed; name of the payer; name of the payee; the date of issue; and signature of the drawer. The
draft is inva1id if lacking anyone of above items.
The p1ace of issue and the place of payment are the relative record items. Recording or not does not affect the validity of the draft. Therefore, the reason of Jia's refuse payment is false.
(2)The reason for the acceptor's refuse payment is invalid. This is a draft with payable in a defined time after the issuance, the bearer shall present the draft for payment within 10 days from the date of maturity,and the time for Ding's presentation of payment meets the requirements, so the reason for the acceptor's pay-ment rejection is inva1id.
(3) Ding who requires Bing, Yi, and A to pay on behalf of Ding is exercising the right of recourse.
(4) Yi' s reason is invalid. According to the law of Instrument, the bearer may exercise the right of recourse against any one, several or all of them without following the order of the debtor of the draft. Therefore, that Yi asking Bing to pay first, in the debtor's order, is invalid.
(5) The guarantor A has the right of recourse after he assumed the liability of guarantee. According to the law of Instrument, the guarantor becomes the bearer after he paying off the debts to the ex-bearer, and has the right of recourse against the guarantee and his predecessors. Therefore, the guarantor A can exercise the right of recourse to the drawer Jia after he fulfils his liability of guaranty.
