根据下面资料,回答题
The Department of Housing and Urban Development is proposing to raise the bar
for civil rights groups seeking to prove that a landlord, insurance company or lender is guilty of housing discrimination. The proposal would force civil rights groups to jump over five hurdles, instead of three, to demonstrate that a policy has had a discriminatory effect that violates the Fair Housing Act of 1968. The propsal also maps out how landlords and other defendants can successfully fight back against those claims and states that the Fair
Housing Act does not override state laws that regulate the business of insurance.
Civil rights groups have long used analyses of the effect of policies to show that
those policies have harmed minority groups. Such analyses have been used to uncover
discrimination in an era when racial prejudice can be more subtle than in the past. Though minority unemployment is at record lows, black homeownership levels have declined to rates not seen since the 1960s.
"This effort to turn back the clock on civil rights is coming at a most inopportune time, and the Trump administration is keenly aware of it," said Lisa Rice, the president of the National Fair Housing Alliance. Civil rights groups fear that the Trump administration's new rule will make it far harder to challenge housing discrimination. She Marilyn If ill, the
president and director counsel of the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, called the five-part requirement "an incredible and extraordinary burden" that makes it "virtually impossible to prevail." The proposed change dates to last summer when the standards for discrimination was
announced to be amended. The new rule would force those initiating lawsuits not only to show that a specific housing policy has a discriminatory effect, but also to show that the effect is "arbitrary and unnecessary" in achieving a "legitimate objective." There must also be a "causal link" between the specific policy and the discriminatory effect.
Ms. Ifill said that rather than comply with the Supreme Court's ruling, the proposed
rule advanced regulations far beyond the court's prescriptions. "It is important to see the development and enactment of these rules for what they are. This is what those who stand against the Fair Housing Act will not accomplish in the United States Supreme Court," she said. But Roger Clegg, the general counsel of the conservative Center for Equal Opportunity, applauded the changes and said they were in line with the Supreme Court ruling. But at the same time, he suggested that the court had made a mistake. "Current policies force people to take race into account in setting housing policies," he said, "which is exactly what the civil rights laws should discourage people from doing."
The Department of Housing and Urban Development intends to
参考答案
C
答案解析
总体评述
【题源揭示】本文源于2019年8月2日的New York Times(《纽约时报》)。题目是
Trump Proposal Would Raise Bar for proving Housing Discrimination(《特朗普的提案将提高证明住房歧视的门槛》)。
【文章大意】全文从美国住房和城市发展部提议提高民权组织证明存在住房歧视门槛引出话题,然后对新提议进行了分析:民权组织认为新提议伤害了少数群体,加大了挑战住房歧视的难度;国家公平住房联盟认为新规定不合时宜,而有色人种协会法律辩护和教育基金会主席兼主任法律顾问谢里琳·伊菲尔认为新规定几乎不可能得到执行。最后,文章列举了两个人对于新规定的不同观点:谢里琳·伊菲尔认为新规定没有遵守最高法院的裁决,超出法院的规定;而保守派机会均等中心总顾问罗格·克莱格却对新规定表示赞赏,称这些变化符合最高法院的裁决。
【试题类型】推理引申题。。
【解题思路】根据题干关键信息The Department of Housing and Urban Development定位
到第一段。该段指出The Department of Housing and Urban Development is proposing
to ralse the bar for civil rights groups seeking to prove that a landlord,insurance
company or lender is guilty of housing discrimination.(美国住房和城市发展部提议,提高民权组织寻求证明房东、保险公司或贷款机构存在住房歧视的门槛),由此可推断,民权组织一直认为房东、保险公司或贷款机构存在住房歧视,美国住房和城市发展部提议提高对于民权组织寻求证明的门槛其实是为了保护房东、保险公司和贷款机构的利益,故选项[C]为正确答案。
【干扰排除】由文章第一段可知,美国住房和城市发展部的提议是为了提高民权组织寻求房东、保险公司或贷款机构存在住房歧视证明的门槛,并未提及对少数族裔存在住房歧视问题,故选项[A]应排除。第一段说的是美国住房和城市发展部提议提高对民权组织的门槛,故选
项[B] oppose putting obstacles to civil rights groups“反对给民权组织设置障碍”正反混淆,应排除。原文并未提及民权组织要证实一项歧视性的政策,故选项[D]force civil rightsgroups to certify a discriminatory policy“迫使民权组织证实一项歧视性的政策”也应排除。
【题源揭示】本文源于2019年8月2日的New York Times(《纽约时报》)。题目是
Trump Proposal Would Raise Bar for proving Housing Discrimination(《特朗普的提案将提高证明住房歧视的门槛》)。
【文章大意】全文从美国住房和城市发展部提议提高民权组织证明存在住房歧视门槛引出话题,然后对新提议进行了分析:民权组织认为新提议伤害了少数群体,加大了挑战住房歧视的难度;国家公平住房联盟认为新规定不合时宜,而有色人种协会法律辩护和教育基金会主席兼主任法律顾问谢里琳·伊菲尔认为新规定几乎不可能得到执行。最后,文章列举了两个人对于新规定的不同观点:谢里琳·伊菲尔认为新规定没有遵守最高法院的裁决,超出法院的规定;而保守派机会均等中心总顾问罗格·克莱格却对新规定表示赞赏,称这些变化符合最高法院的裁决。
【试题类型】推理引申题。。
【解题思路】根据题干关键信息The Department of Housing and Urban Development定位
到第一段。该段指出The Department of Housing and Urban Development is proposing
to ralse the bar for civil rights groups seeking to prove that a landlord,insurance
company or lender is guilty of housing discrimination.(美国住房和城市发展部提议,提高民权组织寻求证明房东、保险公司或贷款机构存在住房歧视的门槛),由此可推断,民权组织一直认为房东、保险公司或贷款机构存在住房歧视,美国住房和城市发展部提议提高对于民权组织寻求证明的门槛其实是为了保护房东、保险公司和贷款机构的利益,故选项[C]为正确答案。
【干扰排除】由文章第一段可知,美国住房和城市发展部的提议是为了提高民权组织寻求房东、保险公司或贷款机构存在住房歧视证明的门槛,并未提及对少数族裔存在住房歧视问题,故选项[A]应排除。第一段说的是美国住房和城市发展部提议提高对民权组织的门槛,故选
项[B] oppose putting obstacles to civil rights groups“反对给民权组织设置障碍”正反混淆,应排除。原文并未提及民权组织要证实一项歧视性的政策,故选项[D]force civil rightsgroups to certify a discriminatory policy“迫使民权组织证实一项歧视性的政策”也应排除。
你可能感兴趣的试题
A.illustrate the achievements obtained by civil rights groups
A.illustrate the achievements obtained by civil rights groups
B.demonstrate the continuous decline in minority unemployment
B.demonstrate the continuous decline in minority unemployment
C.show the severe situation of current housing discrimination
C.show the severe situation of current housing discrimination
D.prove diminishing racial prejudice against black people
D.prove diminishing racial prejudice against black people
A.insignificant
A.Insignificant
B.challenging
B.challenging
C.accurate
C.accurate
D.inappropriate
D.inappropriate
A.have decided to violate the Fair Housing Act of 1968
A.have decided to violate the Fair Housing Act of 1968
B.have exerted their energies to uncover housing discrimination
B.have exerted their energies to uncover housing discrimination
C.think it is not that hard to challenge housing discrimination
C.think it is not that hard to challenge housing discrimination
D.suggest Trump administration's new rule is a mistake
D.suggest Trump administration's new rule is a mistake