根据下面资料,回答题
Science is supposedly based on evidence, but in reality, for most people, it is based on trust.
Scientific evidence is mostly inaccessible. Scientific journals are difficult to obtain and their articles are written in a specialized language that is incomprehensible to all but a few experts in the field. We trust what those experts say about their results without having the ability to question the results ourselves. We trust that some knowledgeable person would question them if necessary.
And so, historically, the reputation of individual scientists has been important in facilitating the spread of scientific theories and discoveries. If a scientist is, or can appear to be, trustworthy, so might that scientist's ideas. That's why Robert Boyle's name appears on the reports produced in his 17th- century lab, even though his technicians did the experimental work, took the notes and in some cases even wrote the reports themselves.
This can lead to odd consequences. For example, one of the best ways to appear trustworthy is to already be associated with a popular theory or discovery. Sociologists Robert Merton and Harriet Zuckerman identified how this can result in the "Matthew effect," a principle derived from Matthew 25:29, "For unto every one that hath shall be given, and he shall have abundance: but from him that hath not shall be taken even that which he hath." In other words, recognizable scientists receive disproportionate credit, and therefore trust, in a repeating cycle. Those scientists who are unrecognizable, whose names are inglorious, have the credit for their work allocated elsewhere; that is, of course, if their work is even appreciated in the first place.
If we don't recognize who the thousands of individuals are that make up these big science projects, and if it is so difficult to learn who the literal authors are that present the evidence on their behalf, in whom are we placing our trust? In "science" itself, I would say, regardless of the integrity or rigor of the individual scientist~ involved; in whoever or whatever organization has the credentials to be regarded as scientific. Our trust has shifted from the individual to the enterprise.
But trusting the enterprise of science itself leads to its own problems. What if someone thinks that someone else is an expert when they aren't? What if someone trusts someone else, even an expert, who lies? These scenarios open the enterprise of science to abuse. The most blatant display of this abuse is presented in the book Merchants of Doubt, where experts and supposed experts use their scientific credibility to obscure the consensus on issues ranging from acid rain to tobacco smoke to global warming.
It can be learned from the first paragraph that '
参考答案
B
答案解析
总体分析
本文节选自Scientific American(《科学美国人》),原文标题为0ur Trust in Science Is Complicated(我们对科学的信任是复杂的)。本文首段指出,科学本应该是建立在证据之上的,但现在科学建立在信任的基础上。第二、三段指出根据科学家的声誉来判断可信性会导致科学界的两极分化。第四段指出我们对科学的信任已从科学家转移到科学事业。最后一段指出对科学事业本身的信任会导致科学事业遭到滥用。
试题解析
It can be learned fromt he first Paragraph 1 that21.从第一段可以得知A.there is controversy over the basis ofscience.A.对于科学的基础存在争议。B.few people can read articles in scientific iournals.B.很少有人能阅读科学期刊上的文章。C.we have no right to question the scientific results.C.我们没有权利质疑科学结果。D.1anguage of scientific journals should be easy to D.科学期刊的语言应该通俗易懂。understand.
【定位词】the first
Paragraph 1
【答案解析】B事实细节题。根据定位词定位到第一段。该段第三句指出,科学期刊很难获得,而且它们的文章是用专业语言所写,除了少数专家之外,多数人都无法理解(incomprehensible to all but all but a fewexperts in the field 0由此可知,只有少数专家能够理解科学期刊的专业语言,B项是该句的同义表达,故为正确答案。
【干扰排除】A项利用首段首句“科学应该建立在证据的基础上,但实际上,对大多数人来说,科学建立在信任的基础上”主观臆断出“对于科学的基础存在争议”,controversy一词原文未提及,故排除;倒数第二句指出without having the ability to question the results ourselves,而C项改为have no right to question thescientific resu Its,明显与文意不符,故排除;D项由“除了少数专家之外,多数人都无法理解期刊的专业语言”而来,但选项内容与本文无关,故排除。
本文节选自Scientific American(《科学美国人》),原文标题为0ur Trust in Science Is Complicated(我们对科学的信任是复杂的)。本文首段指出,科学本应该是建立在证据之上的,但现在科学建立在信任的基础上。第二、三段指出根据科学家的声誉来判断可信性会导致科学界的两极分化。第四段指出我们对科学的信任已从科学家转移到科学事业。最后一段指出对科学事业本身的信任会导致科学事业遭到滥用。
试题解析
It can be learned fromt he first Paragraph 1 that21.从第一段可以得知A.there is controversy over the basis ofscience.A.对于科学的基础存在争议。B.few people can read articles in scientific iournals.B.很少有人能阅读科学期刊上的文章。C.we have no right to question the scientific results.C.我们没有权利质疑科学结果。D.1anguage of scientific journals should be easy to D.科学期刊的语言应该通俗易懂。understand.
【定位词】the first
Paragraph 1
【答案解析】B事实细节题。根据定位词定位到第一段。该段第三句指出,科学期刊很难获得,而且它们的文章是用专业语言所写,除了少数专家之外,多数人都无法理解(incomprehensible to all but all but a fewexperts in the field 0由此可知,只有少数专家能够理解科学期刊的专业语言,B项是该句的同义表达,故为正确答案。
【干扰排除】A项利用首段首句“科学应该建立在证据的基础上,但实际上,对大多数人来说,科学建立在信任的基础上”主观臆断出“对于科学的基础存在争议”,controversy一词原文未提及,故排除;倒数第二句指出without having the ability to question the results ourselves,而C项改为have no right to question thescientific resu Its,明显与文意不符,故排除;D项由“除了少数专家之外,多数人都无法理解期刊的专业语言”而来,但选项内容与本文无关,故排除。
你可能感兴趣的试题
A.his high personal reputation.
A.his high personal reputation.
B.his trustworthy ideas about science.
B.his trustworthy ideas about science.
C.his scientific study of history.
C.his scientific study of history.
D.his reports in 17th-century lab.
D.his reports in 17th-century lab.
A.renowned.
A.renowned.
B.unknown.
B.obscure.
C.unusual.
C.unusual.
D.familiar.
D.familiar.
A.unfair income distribution.
A.unfair income distribution.
B.discredited scientific findings.
B.discredited scientific findings.
C.a vicious circle among scientists.
C.a vicious circle among scientists.
D.polarization in the scientific community.
D.polarization in the scientific community.