单选题
题号 #6528352

The author suggests in the last paragraph that the bar group's new ideas

进入在线模考

参考答案

D

答案解析

[信息锁定]第六段作者首先驳斥加州律师协会的回信,认为此时中断研究将适得其反(cutting offresearch now would be counterproductive),继而分别向立法机构和政府提出建议,指出应评估新想法的价值,并为公众利益而行动。可见,作者认为律师团队对新方案的研究不应被中断,因为这些方案是符合公众利益的,D项正确。
[解题技巧]A项将第六段④句关键信息Lawmakers would still have plenty of opportunity toevaluate it,negotiate the fine points的含义由“立法者仍有机会对这些想法进行评估和商榷,故不必急于要求将其摒弃”曲解为“律师团队的想法需要重新进行严肃评估”.言外之意就变成了“律师团队的新想法可能存在问题或缺陷,不应直接予以批准。而应重新评估”,与作者在文中暗示的对这些想法的支持态度相悖。B项张冠李戴,作者认为“州律师协会此时中断律师团队的研究将适得其反”,而不是“律师团队的新想法会适得其反”。C项利用第六段⑤句碎片信息suppress competition设置干扰,作者认为政府摒弃这些创新想法将会遏制市场竞争,言外之意是这些创新想法能够鼓励竞争,选项与作者观点完全相反。
 【全文翻译】
 数百万加州人面临驱逐、追债或监护权纠纷,他们本应从律师援助中受益,却往往聘请不起律师。
加州律师协会正试图解决这一问题,他们探讨提供低成本、高质量法律援助的方案,包含许可准律师执业和创造在线援助。但是,这些令人振奋的想法威胁了法律行业的既存现况,遭遇了来自律师和立法机构的强烈政治逆风,前者抵制新型法律服务带来的竞争,后者是律师协会每年经费的决定者。
  提出“许可非律师成员执业”想法的律师团队已经拟出了一个试点项目计划。该计划将开创一个新的品类:持牌准律师,其所受的培训比律师少。可将这些持牌准律师看作法律领域的从业护士,他们经过培训并获准以低于医生的价格(向患者)提供很多常规治疗。
  随着试点项目计划的推进.律师协会必须解决批评者提出的关于“有必要保护消费者”的关切。“(持牌)准律师无须在律师的监督下执业,对他们的信赖在某些情况下可能会对身处弱势的加州人造成不可逆转的法律后果0'17加州总检察长罗布·邦塔在给律师协会的一封信中写道,他要求对该计划进行一些修改。
  另一个想法是创建新的技术平台,来帮助人们自己解决基本的法律问题。这一想法包含一项受监控的、有时限的试验,该试验要求改变(现有)管制法律业务所有权的法律和规则,以便律师与非律师合伙,推出比聘请律师更实惠的服务。
  这与(当前)加州律师的业务模式相去甚远,也引起了律师们的强烈反对,他们认为这将引发不公平的竞争,并将消费者置于受欺诈的风险之中。众议员马克·斯通和参议员汤姆·翁贝格在上个月写给律师协会的信中提到.这项试验“可能会成为一个公开的邀请,使得利润驱动型公司、对冲基金或其他机构趁虚而人,在缺乏适当的法律培训、规则监管、律师一客户关系中固有的保护以及足够的纪律约束的情况下提供法律服务或直接从事法律工作.最终损害需要法律援助的加州人民的利益”。他们叮嘱律师协会官员要将注意力集中在监管律师的不当行为以及探索如何授权更多律师执业上。
  律师协会官员在回信中表示,他们将要求受托人董事会考虑“解散或暂停”正在为新的法律技术平台和伙伴关系出谋划策的律师团队。但现在中断研究将适得其反。律师团队应该完成其研究并提出一个方案。立法者仍有足够的机会对该方案进行评估,就其细微之处进行磋商,或者如果不合要求,就将其废止。政府不应不加考虑就为受到创新者挑战的行业消除竞争,而应评估新想法的价值,并为公众利益而行动。在这件事上,重点必须放在加州人民的需求上,他们应该在寻求公正之路上享有公平的机会。

你可能感兴趣的试题

1 根据以下材料,回答题
America's supreme court has issued a momentous ruling--one that will have far-reachingconsequences for the government's ability to curb the greenhouse-gas emissions.In West Virginiavs.Environmental Protection Agency, the court sharply limited the EPA's power to regulate themillions of tonnes of greenhouse gases discharged by coal-burning power plants each year.TheClean Air Act, the majority ruled, does not permit the agency to reshape the power network byrelying more heavily on cleaner sources like solar and wind power.
  In his majority opinion, joined by all five of his conservative colleagues, Chief Justice JohnRoberts described the Clean Power Plan--the emissions guidelines that the EPA developed underthe Clean Air Act--as an "unheralded" scheme affecting "a significant portion of the Americaneconomy".Reducing carbon dioxide emissions and forcing "a nationwide transition away from theuse of coal to generate electricity", he wrote, "may be a sensible solution to the crisis of theday", but "it is not plausible that Congress gave EPA the authority to adopt on its own such aregulatory scheme".
  The Clean Air Act may empower the EPA to regulate greenhouse-gas emissions, Chief JusticeRoberts wrote, but "separation of powers principles and a practical understanding of legislativeintent" require "clear congressional authorisation" before systemic regulations affecting the entirepower network can be drawn up.The decision did not write off all future alternatives for what theClean Air Act stipulates as a "best system of emission reduction".
  Under the court's ruling, when the EPA develops national emissions guidelines for existingpower plants it must rely only on technological solutions that can be applied by existing plants,without assuming a fundamental change in their nature.In other words, guidelines must be draftedthat allow a coal-fired power plant to remain a coal-fired power plant.In fact, power companiesmay find that replacing coal with renewables is more economical, as installing renewables becomesincreasingly competitive with fossil fuels, and in particular coal.
  Justice Elena Kagan's dissent expressed frustration with the majority's attitude towards "themost pressing environmental challenge of our time".Where the majority favours strong judicialoversight of "unelected officials", the dissenters would give regulatory bodies more leeway."Thesubject matter of the regulation here," Justice Kagan wrote, "makes the court's intervention all themore troubling." Justices do "not have a clue" about "how to address climate change", she added.With stakes as high as the future of the planet, it was outrageous that the "court appoints itself--instead of Congress or the expert agency--the decisionmaker on climate policy".
  By ruling in favour of the coal producers, the Supreme Court has restricted Mr Biden's abilityto decarbonise the American power sector, responsible for 25% of the country's emissions, and thesecond-largest after transport.Achieving the climate target is not impossible without system-wideregulations on power-plant emissions.And other options, such as clean-energy tax credits andstate-led regulation can pick up some of the slack.But by restricting the ways in which the EPA candevise its guidelines, the Supreme Court has considerably depleted the climate toolbox.
It can be learned from Paragraph 1 that America's supreme court
A.overturned the Clean Air Act.
B.ruled against coal-burning power plants.
C.curbed the EPA's power to regulate greenhouse-gas emissions.
D.prohibited the government from decarbonising the power sector.
A.runs counter to the Clean Air Act.
B.is a hindrance to America's economy.
C.is drawn up without congressional authorisation.
D.can't count as a best system of emission reduction.
A.encourage technological innovations.
B.respect the nature of power plants.
C.ensure a national transition to renewables.
D.entail different sets of standards.
找试题 · 找答案 · 找资料 在线模考