根据以下材料,回答题
A recent paper makes an upsetting claim about the state of science: nonreplicable studies arecited more often than replicable ones.If a substantial proportion of science fails to meet the norm ofreplicability, then this work won't provide a solid basis for decision-making.Failure to reproduceresults may delay the use of science in developing new medicines and technologies.It may alsoundermine public trust, making it harder to get Americans vaccinated or to act on climate change.
In the new study, the authors tracked papers in psychology journals, economics journals, andScience and Nature with documented failures of replication.The results are disturbing: papers thatcouldn't be replicated were cited more than average, even after the news of the reproducibilityfailure had been published, and only 12 percent of postexposure citations acknowledged the failure.
A potential explanation for the finding involves a two-edged sword.Academics valorizenovelty : new findings, new results, "cutting-edge" and "disruptive" research.On one level thismakes sense.If science is a process of discovery, then papers that offer new and surprising thingsare more likely to represent a possible big advance than papers that strengthen the foundations ofexisting knowledge or modestly extend its domain of applicability.Moreover, both academics andlaypeople experience surprises as more interesting than the predictable, the normal and theordinary.The problem is that surprising results are surprising because they go against whatexperience has led us to believe, which means that there's a good chance they're wrong.
The authors of the citation study theorize that reviewers and editors apply lower standards to"showy" or dramatic papers than to those that incrementally advance the field and that highlyinteresting papers attract more attention, discussion and citations.In other words, there is a bias infavor of novelty.
Novel claims have the potential to be very valuable.If something surprises us, it indicates thatwe might have something to learn from it.But sometimes things are surprising and wrong.Researchers, reviewers and editors should take steps to correct their bias in favor of novelty.
As the authors of the citation study note, many replication studies focus on splashy papers thathave received a lot of attention.But these are more likely than average to fail to hold up on furtherscrutiny.A review focused on showy, high-profile papers is not going to be reflective of science atlarge--a failure of the norm of representativeness.In one case, a paper flagging reproducibilityproblems failed to reveal the researchers' own methods, yet this paper has been highly cited.Soscientists must be careful that in their quest to flag papers that couldn't be replicated, they don'tcreate flashy but flimsy claims of their own.
What does the recent paper reveal about the state of science?
参考答案
A
答案解析
【信息锁定】首段首句引出最近一篇论文就科学现状的发现:不可复现的研究比可复现的研究被引用的次数更多。②句以“大量科学研究不能满足可复现这一标准”进一步阐明首句的发现,表明科学界之后可能会存在大量不可复现的论文。第二段末句再次以研究的具体调查结果详述研究发现。由此可知,科学界对不可复现的研究存在过度关注。A项正确。
【解题技巧】B、C、D三项是对首段②③④句所述内容“科研无法为决策制定提供坚实基础…‘推迟科学在技术研发上的应用”“削弱公众信任”的合理理解,但均是作者提出的大量科学研究不可复现的消极影响,并不是论文发现的内容。
【解题技巧】B、C、D三项是对首段②③④句所述内容“科研无法为决策制定提供坚实基础…‘推迟科学在技术研发上的应用”“削弱公众信任”的合理理解,但均是作者提出的大量科学研究不可复现的消极影响,并不是论文发现的内容。
你可能感兴趣的试题
A.can consolidate the existing scientific knowledge
B.might promise to be major scientific progress
C.can modestly enlarge the applicability domain of knowledge
D.may get divided responses from the scientific community
A.apply loose standards to high-profile papers
B.be more alert to attractive but possibly wrong studies
C.prefer papers that moderately advance the field
D.turn down papers that are potentially biased
A.pay more attention to nonreplicable studies
B.stop citing papers that miss research methods
C.further improve the review system
D.flag reproducibility problems convincingly